KCA News & Media

Press Release

Press Release

Oriental Medicine Practice-Related Disputes 게시글 상세보기 - 등록일, 조회수, 첨부파일, 상세내용, 이전글, 다음글 제공
Oriental Medicine Practice-Related Disputes
Date 2007-08-08 Hit 941
첨부파일

For the past seven years since April 1999, the Korea Consumer Protection Board (KCPB) has analyzed 115 redress cases involving oriental medicine and the results are described in the tables below.
 
[Table 1] Redress Cases Handled by Type of Treatment
Unit: Number ofCases (%)
Oriental Medicine
63 (54.8)
Cupping
3 (2.6)
Acupuncture
25 (21.7)
Diagnosis
3 (2.6)
Massage
6 (5.2)
Moxibustion
2 (1.7)
Physical Therapy
5 (4.4)
Others
3 (2.6)
Examination
5 (4.4)
Total
115 (100.0)
 
[Table 2] Redress Cases Handled by Type of Accident
Unit: Number of Cases (%)
Harmful Effects of Medicine
31 (27.0)
Burns
3 (2.6)
Relapse
31 (27.0)
Death
3 (2.6)
Ineffectiveness
16 (13.9)
Pneumothorax
2 (1.7)
Infection
13 (11.3)
Hematomas
2 (1.7)
Erroneous Diagnosis
9 (7.8)
Others
5 (4.4)
 
■ Toxic hepatitis caused by oriental medicine intake
 
Among 63 cases involving oriental medicine, nearly a majority of the cases (49.2%) related to relapses. The most frequent relapse was toxic hepatitis (22 cases) which destroys liver cells.
 
In regard to occurrences of toxic hepatitis, among 15 verified oriental medicine prescriptions, 7 contained 8 types of oriental medicine ingredients (ephedra, sulphate, ternate, etc.) designated by the Association of Korean Oriental Medicine as containing toxic substances. The AKOM categorizes 87 types of oriental medicine ingredients that contain toxic substances.
 
 ■ 42.9% of cases involving infections related to acupuncture & cupping
 
Among 28 medical disputes involving acupuncture and cupping, 12 cases (42.9%) were caused by infections. There is a likely risk for infection when receiving acupuncture and cupping treatment as it directly invades the body. Infections are easily caused by applying acupuncture or cupping while the patient still has on clothes or socks. However, there are currently no laws that regulate unsanitary treatment in oriental medicine.
 
 ■ Patients victimized due to lack of emergency care by oriental medicine hospitals
 
As for cases involving doctor’s negligence, 30.4% related to ‘inattentiveness’ followed by ‘insufficient explanation’ (28.7%) and ‘failure to admit patients at the right time or lack of cooperation with western hospitals’ (11.3%). 
 
In a case where the oriental medicine doctor failed to provide sufficient information, he didn’t inform the patient on side effects or intake method which resulted in the patient continuing to take the medicine without realizing that symptoms were actually side effects. 
 
Based on the above findings, KCPB proposed to the Ministry of Health and Welfare to ▲ designate & control oriental medicine ingredients that are toxic ▲ revise the Medical Practice Act related to preventing & control infections by oriental medicine hospitals and ▲ establish a cooperative system among emergency medical services within western & oriental hospitals to provide more effective treatment.
 
Furthermore, KCPB made a request to the Association of Korean Oriental Medicine to ▲ develop a guideline on hospital infection control & prevention ▲ provide long-term education on infection and provide accurate treatment and ▲ guidance for prescriptions. 
♣ Consumer Precautionary Measures Related to Oriental Medicine ♣ 
▣ Describe the specific symptoms to your oriental medicine doctor.
▣ Consult with a doctor before taking oriental medicine and western medicine together.
▣ Receive detailed explanation on intake method and side effects of oriental medicine.
▣ If there is no sign of improvement or there are signs of side effects (fatigue, upset stomach,
     jaundice, pruritus, urine color change, etc.), stop taking the medicine and consult with a doctor.
▣ Beware of oriental medicine doctors who emphasize therapeutic effect.
▣ Beware of infections when receiving acupuncture or cupping treatment.
▣ In the case of an emergency, western medical treatment may be more appropriate so make sure to
     select the right medical center.
▣ Make sure to keep evidence material such as treatment records in case medical disputes occur.
 
Source: Consumer Dispute Settlement Department II
 
Next Harmful Substances Found in New Furniture
Prev Banned Substances Contained in ‘BLUECAP’ Products
TOP